Retention Of Title Agreement Italiano

Posted on: April 11th, 2021 by localoneway No Comments

“Member States provide, in accordance with the applicable national provisions of private international law, that the seller retain ownership of the goods until it is fully paid for, if a property reserve clause has been expressly agreed between the buyer and the seller prior to the delivery of the goods.” 17 In its reply, the Italian Government argues that the property reserve clause is considered an ancillary condition of the sales contract, the validity and effectiveness of which are not subject to a particular condition of form, the only condition of validity being that this clause was agreed at the time of the conclusion of the sale contract. “It is important to ensure that creditors are able to exercise the property reserve throughout the Community without discrimination if the property reserve clause is valid under the applicable national provisions of private international law.” 26 It follows from its wording that this provision imposes the effects of a property reserve clause on the buyer and seller, which can be retained until the full payment of the goods. It also notes that, in order to be valid, such a clause must have been the subject of an explicit agreement between the buyer and the seller before the delivery of the goods. 7 The sale with reserve ownership is governed by Italian law in Chapter 1, paragraph 3, of Title III of Chapter IV of the Civil Code. Court judgment (second chamber) of 26 October 2006.#Commission of the European Communities/Italian Republic.#Failure of a Member State on the implementation of obligations – Directive 2000/35/EC – Art. #Case C-302/05. 27 It should be added that the reference to the national provisions designated by private international law in Article 4, paragraph 1 of Directive 2000/35 concerns the conditions of validity of the property reserve. Property reserve clauses must obtain the right of sellers to their goods, often until the full payment of the purchase price, and are often included in the terms and conditions of sale. 3) “property reserve”: the contractual agreement under which the seller retains ownership of the goods in question until the price is fully paid; In light of the wording of Article 4, paragraph 1, Of Directive 2000/35 and the purpose of this directive, it cannot be inferred from this provision that it must violate rules other than those which expressly provide that the seller and the purchaser may expressly accept a reserve of ownership clause before the delivery of the goods and, on the one hand, that the seller may retain ownership of the goods until the goods are paid for in full. Therefore, national rules on the applicability of property reserve clauses against third parties whose rights are not affected by Directive 2000/35 remain exclusively governed by the national legal orders of the Member States. 22 In order to determine whether the Commission`s application is justified, Article 4, paragraph 1 of Directive 2000/35 should be examined and whether this provision affects the provisions adopted by a Member State with regard to the applicability of property reserve clauses to third parties.

Comments are closed.